Title IX Transgender Rules Blocked Again; Now at More Than 700 Colleges and Universities

Supreme Court's Killing Off The Chevron Doctrine is Preserving Protections For Girls and Women
By: Public Interest Law Professor John Banzhaf
 
WASHINGTON - Aug. 1, 2024 - PRLog -- An Oklahoma judge has become the latest to put a hold on enforcement of a new federal rule which would have permitted any male claiming to the female to use restrooms, showers, and locker rooms where students undress reserved for females, and grant them various privileges and protections designed to benefit girls and women.

Enforcement of new Title IX rules has been almost uniformly blocked due to the Supreme Court's recent decision doing away with the Chevron Doctrine.

This is one of the first major results of a recent Supreme Court decision which finally killed off the Chevron Doctrine.  Now courts are permitted to use common sense in interpreting language in statutes which govern agencies, rather than having to accept even the most fanciful interpretation offered by the agencies themselves, says Prof. Banzhaf, who explained things this way.

When the Supreme Court recently tossed out the 40-year-old Chevron Doctrine which required courts to adopt whatever definition agencies decided to give to words in its statute which might arguably seem to be ambiguous, many bemoaned that agencies would no longer be able to protect the public, and that judges with no scientific training would begin making scientific and medical judgments.

For example here's how a popular legal website reported it:  John Roberts Says Judges Should Decide How Much Rat Poison Is Too Much For Your Hot Dogs (https://abovethelaw.com/2024/06/john-roberts-chevron-dumb...)

So, in extreme situations, men with beards, but claiming to be female, were offered pap smears, and allowed to compete against girls and women and severely injure them in sports where strength and size are major factors, notes the law professor, who helped add "sexual identity" to the protected categories at his own university.

M2F transgender students were also permitted to exhibit their male genitalia to females, and to view the naked bodies of girls and women, while in female showers, locker rooms, and restrooms.  Ironically, girls who objected to this requirement were then discriminated against by being punished and/or required to change clothing in toilet stalls.

Many engaging in sports have been severely injured by M2F transgender athletes they were forced to compete against, including men who looked exactly like men
A Bearded 6 Feet Tall Player Injures 3 Girl Athletes, Again *** M2F Transgender Are Athletes Disabling Females in Many Different Sports (http://prsync.com/george-washington-university/a-bearded-...)

This occurs even though those seeking these extra protections or privileges need not offer any proof that they really believe themselves to be female.  Indeed, they can demand the opportunity to shower with girls and women even when sporting a beard, and making no effect to dress or otherwise appear female.

http://banzhaf.net/   jbanzhaf3ATgmail.com   @profbanzhaf

Contact
GW Law
***@gmail.com
End
Source:Public Interest Law Professor John Banzhaf
Email:***@gmail.com
Tags:Title IX transgender
Industry:Legal
Location:Washington - District of Columbia - United States
Account Email Address Verified     Account Phone Number Verified     Disclaimer     Report Abuse



Like PRLog?
9K2K1K
Click to Share